Please read this truly fascinating and excellent article on the complex and ancient origins of the Scythians.
Looking at archeology and genetics going back into prehistory, this very long, detailed article explores multiple cultures of Central Asia and their complex ethnic origins and admixture events. This must have taken months to research and write.
Also check out the other articles and subscribe to the author, if you're into this sort of thing.
Looking at archeology and genetics going back into prehistory, this very long, detailed article explores multiple cultures of Central Asia and their complex ethnic origins and admixture events. This must have taken months to research and write.
Also check out the other articles and subscribe to the author, if you're into this sort of thing.
Substack
The origin of Scythians - part I: The Circum-Altai region during the late Bronze Age
Unraveling the origins of the Iron Age nomads of the Eurasian steppes, the Scythians (in the broad sense), is a complicated topic that historians and archaeologists have wrestled with for centuries.
β€22π11π₯7π€3π€©1
When I grew up, I learned about the prehistory of central and northern Europe from a Roman perspective. The Celts and Germans were mere barbarians who invaded civilised Rome and Greece with nothing but destruction in their hearts. From watching TV and movies, it seemed like the German tribes wore furs and lived in the woods.
It wasn't until much later that I discovered the incredible achievements of not only the Iron Age people but their Bronze Age ancestors, expressed in artefacts like stunning goldwork.
For thousands of years, these wealthy societies produced genius artists working in gold, especially from the Bell Beaker era onwards. They produced large and sometimes heavy wearable pieces, and also created the finest details with stamps and etching, and many other complex techniques requiring masterful working and annealing.
It's surprising how much gold survived from this era, considering how much must have been melted down in the centuries since after tomb raiding and accidental discovery.
It wasn't until much later that I discovered the incredible achievements of not only the Iron Age people but their Bronze Age ancestors, expressed in artefacts like stunning goldwork.
For thousands of years, these wealthy societies produced genius artists working in gold, especially from the Bell Beaker era onwards. They produced large and sometimes heavy wearable pieces, and also created the finest details with stamps and etching, and many other complex techniques requiring masterful working and annealing.
It's surprising how much gold survived from this era, considering how much must have been melted down in the centuries since after tomb raiding and accidental discovery.
β€56π16π€©8π₯4π2π1
I've mentioned these massive, Nordic Bronze Age ritual axes before a couple of times.
Usually there are a couple comments saying "Typical academics, saying everything is ritual. Obviously they were weapons!"
In fact, the axes are blunt. Now, blunt axes this size, especially with a curve like that to focus the force could still make excellent weapons for cracking skulls and breaking arms.
But they're not solid bronze! They actually had cores of CLAY, over which molten bronze was cunningly cast. The outer skin of bronze is rather thin.
Level 100 Bronze Casting skill.
Why did they do it that way? To save metal, presumably.
What did the axes mean to them? Wow, that's a great question, yeah π
Usually there are a couple comments saying "Typical academics, saying everything is ritual. Obviously they were weapons!"
In fact, the axes are blunt. Now, blunt axes this size, especially with a curve like that to focus the force could still make excellent weapons for cracking skulls and breaking arms.
But they're not solid bronze! They actually had cores of CLAY, over which molten bronze was cunningly cast. The outer skin of bronze is rather thin.
Level 100 Bronze Casting skill.
Why did they do it that way? To save metal, presumably.
What did the axes mean to them? Wow, that's a great question, yeah π
π38π₯23π4β€1
Delightful WHG reconstruction seen on Instagram.
Give the chap a follow to show your support.
https://www.instagram.com/p/C9vdtQ3ObKh/?igsh=aGEyNW50c3g2YXdy
Give the chap a follow to show your support.
https://www.instagram.com/p/C9vdtQ3ObKh/?igsh=aGEyNW50c3g2YXdy
β€34π₯°8π€8
Kristiansen and Larsson consider these bird-boat-wagons from Dupljaja, Serbia dating to perhaps 1300 BC, to be representations of the Indo-European dawn goddess.
Chariots pulled through the sky by birds like swallows or swans were said to carry the sun god to Hyperborea for winter in Ancient Greek (and other IE) mythology.
Chariots pulled through the sky by birds like swallows or swans were said to carry the sun god to Hyperborea for winter in Ancient Greek (and other IE) mythology.
β€30π₯12
Forwarded from TheBeakerLady
Map of the samples locations of the two most common Steppe Eneolithic y haplogroup. This map was created by HurrianFan.
I2-L699 was found in the Sredny Stog culture but also in a Khvalynsk male. It was also found in the CernavodΔ culture and in the Yamnaya. In Anatolia, I2-L699 was found in Hittite related samples. It was also found in Iron Age Swat Valley in Pakistan showing it survived in small amounts in later steppe groups such as Andronovo.
R1b-V1636 was the most common y haplogroup in steppe Eneolithic groups. It was related to but not ancestral to Yamnaya and Corded Ware R1b subclades. However it did show up in a Corded Ware related Single Grave culture male buried in Demark.
Supporters of the western route of Anatolian languages (through the Balkans from steppe) use I2-L699 as genetic support for the hypothesis. While supporters of an eastern route (from CLV groups migrating down through the Caucasus) may point to R1b-V1636 in eastern Anatolia.
Link to original post of the image.
I2-L699 was found in the Sredny Stog culture but also in a Khvalynsk male. It was also found in the CernavodΔ culture and in the Yamnaya. In Anatolia, I2-L699 was found in Hittite related samples. It was also found in Iron Age Swat Valley in Pakistan showing it survived in small amounts in later steppe groups such as Andronovo.
R1b-V1636 was the most common y haplogroup in steppe Eneolithic groups. It was related to but not ancestral to Yamnaya and Corded Ware R1b subclades. However it did show up in a Corded Ware related Single Grave culture male buried in Demark.
Supporters of the western route of Anatolian languages (through the Balkans from steppe) use I2-L699 as genetic support for the hypothesis. While supporters of an eastern route (from CLV groups migrating down through the Caucasus) may point to R1b-V1636 in eastern Anatolia.
Link to original post of the image.
π17β€6π€©2
Forwarded from TheBeakerLady
According to the recently published paper from the Harvard lab on the origins of the Indo-European languages, the roots of the Yamnaya culture is hypothesized to come out of the Mikhaylovka culture. This group forms a bridge from Sredny Stog to Core Yamnaya, expand from Ukraine.
According to one of the paperβs authors, Losif Lazaridis, he had the following to say on his twitter account.
Photo credit
According to one of the paperβs authors, Losif Lazaridis, he had the following to say on his twitter account.
The Yamnaya, proximal scions of the Serednii Stih archaeological culture that preceded them in the Eneolithic North Pontic region, and more distally composed of a mix of CLV newcomers and Dnipro-Don hunter-gatherers, largely eclipsed the previous inhabitants of the steppe. 4/
Source
The Yamnaya's precursors were formed by admixture ca. 4000BCE and experienced an interlude of relative isolation before the emergence of the Yamnaya horizon ca. 3300BCE. Our best guess of where this happened is in the vicinity of Mykhailivka in the Lower Dnipro in Ukraine. 5/
source
Photo credit
π14β€7π₯3
