To those that believe mrekk is the GOAT, what arguments do you think he has over Cookiezi?

Hi r/osugame,

As mentioned in my most recent post a few days ago, I mentioned that I wanted to work on a video project that discusses osu!'s newfound GOAT debate up close, from how it used to be unanimously agreed upon that Cookiezi was undisputedly the greatest osu! player of all time, to now where mrekk has solidified his case through his play in recent times, with many people now considering him to be the greatest. If you'd like, you can read through the full explanation there.

In that post, I asked those those who believe believe Cookiezi is the GOAT over mrekk, what arguments did they have, and now it's time for the other side of this argument. For those who believe mrekk has surpassed Cookiezi's and has become the greatest osu! player of all time, what arguments do you think he has that put him over Cookiezi?

Based on some of the comments I read in my previous post, I think a large portion of the answers in favor of mrekk will be skewed towards mentioning one of several statistics that he dominates (i.e., how he had more pp than the rest of the world combined, the gap between him and #2, the amount of time he has held #1 on the osu! rankings, etc.). Those answers are perfectly valid and acceptable, but the more in-depth these answers are and the more thorough the explanation of why that puts him on top above Cookiezi, the better.

Just like last time, if I like your answer enough, I might include it in my video! Thank you all once again for your help!

https://redd.it/1lpi1e4
@r_osugame

lifeline | Thaehan - Help [Virtuosu!] +HDDT (Nozhomi, 9.73*) 97.34% 1033/1081x 1xMiss | 1101pp (1202pp if FC)
https://redd.it/1lpk82q
@r_osugame

lifeline | Nanaki feat.GUMI - Mousou Kajitsu [Climax] +HDDT (Natsu, 9.87*) 97.64% 817/1038x 1xSB | 1111pp (1233pp if FC)
https://redd.it/1lpl7l7
@r_osugame

lifeline | Shounen Radio - uen [neu] +HDDT (sstari, 10.17*) 95.41% 385/726x 2xMiss | 1020pp (1176pp if FC)
https://redd.it/1lpk122
@r_osugame

RhythmicRS | Ryu* Vs. L.E.D.-G Vs. ZUN - PARADISE GHOST [Extra] +DT (Pokie, 9.10*) 99.65% FC #23 | 872pp
https://redd.it/1lpm0ph
@r_osugame

toro-019 | MiddleIsland - Delrio [From the River] +DT (Dustice, 12.51*) 86.09% 390/1431x 18xMiss LOVED | 501pp if ranked (1184pp if FC) - First DT B rank?
https://redd.it/1lpoudy
@r_osugame

toro-019 | 07th Expansion - rog-unlimitation [AngelHoney] (AngelHoney, 10.31*) +DTHR 96.06% FC #5 | 1308pp | 10 star fc medal!
https://redd.it/1lpq969
@r_osugame

toro-019 | Various Artists - Stream Practice Maps [rog-limitation BPM220] +DTHR 94,21% 2X (556/1241) | (10,92★ loved | NewRulerNA) | 1365pp if ranked (1626 if FC)
https://redd.it/1lpqzaa
@r_osugame

Going to Japan boisss!
https://redd.it/1lps9go
@r_osugame

toro-019 | TJ.Hangneil - Kamui [SHD] +DTHRNF (7odoa, 10.65*) 94.17% 259/967x 10xMiss | 741pp (823pp w/o NF, 1414pp if FC) | acc
https://redd.it/1lprxm9
@r_osugame

Chicony's Interview with Mrekk is out!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FIq3NVk51rg

https://redd.it/1lptxsl
@r_osugame

-L U C K Y- | ONE OK ROCK - American Girls (Juztan Remix) (Extreme, 9.73) +HDDT 98.21% FC | 1093pp | Their First 1k
https://redd.it/1lpvzxt
@r_osugame

Woey became the 1st player who reached 2,000,000,000,000 total score in osu!std!
https://redd.it/1lq08r6
@r_osugame

Most common beatmaps in the top plays of the top 10,000 users
https://redd.it/1lq1avy
@r_osugame

Saiyku | cosMo@BousouP feat. Hatsune Miku, GUMI - MONOCHROME VOICE [EMOTIONLESS] (FrenZ, 9.77*) +HR 96.96% 499/1354 3xMiss #36 💖 | 840pp if ranked (1031pp if FC) | FIRST HR PASS
https://redd.it/1lq070j
@r_osugame

[osu!catch] qwhj79 | DystopiaGround - AugoEidEs [Freezing] +DT (koliron, 8.87*) 99.87% FC | 1264pp | first DT only FC! | this is a story of a man who never gave up!!!!
https://redd.it/1lq23sm
@r_osugame

EZChamp | Aqours - Mitaiken HORIZON [Sunshine] +EZDT (Sotarks, 7.78*) 99.47% FC | 570pp | FIRST EZDT FC!!
https://redd.it/1lq7lpw
@r_osugame

reused | e-ZUKA - Vital Mission in the Spanish Desert [Fourth Wave] +DTNF (Saten, 9.84*) 97.47% 1132/1583 1xMiss | 936pp if ranked (1070pp if FC) | saten 300bpm deathstream
https://redd.it/1lqapim
@r_osugame

avg player: "LaZer iS nOT SiKNaBle YeT" Me: Well see about that...

https://redd.it/1lq5mro
@r_osugame